A run of poor results has ended with the departure of a previously successful SE London manager who earlier had been part of the coaching set-up at Charlton.
Andy Woodman’s exit at League One Bromley, following a 4-0 midweek home defeat by Leicester City, feels harsh in the context of his five-year record at that club and probably a poor decision, even though his side have only two league wins this season.
You’re Bromley, non-league for your entire history until 2024 and you just played the former Premier League champions on an equal footing, for heaven’s sake. That particular result feels more like a correction than a catastrophe.
But while there may be sympathy for Woodman and bemusement at his fate, that is other people’s business. Bromley, despite being geographically close, are barely on most Charlton fans’ radar.
The pertinence of the news to Addicks is to serve as a reminder that football clubs do strange things in times of trouble. Charlton have had 19 managers in 20 years but a period of relative stability since that other former Addicks coach, Nathan Jones, took over in February 2024.
The turmoil in the dugout, at least since 2014, was about the competence of the ownership as much as the doubtful capability of some of the people they brought in to lead the team.
Jones is the third longest-serving Charlton boss since 2006, behind Lee Bowyer (two years, 358 days) and Chris Powell (three years, 56 days). He will overtake Powell at the beginning of April next year if he remains in post. And based on his record he should.
It’s obviously no coincidence that all three of those managers achieved promotion to the Championship and two of them kept the team up, while the third was unlucky not to do so.
Others, notably Johnnie Jackson (195 days), might argue they didn’t get the chance.
Jones has benefited from more supportive ownership than either of the other achievers. Powell was actively undermined and Bowyer, at best, was left to get on with things. In the end, he walked away. Neither has had further success as a manager.
Nevertheless, a run of eight consecutive winless matches feels like a potential watershed for Charlton, even if five of them have been draws. The risk of the club slipping backwards is real and an ownership transparently interested in its resale value is bound to be concerned.
Jones himself said after the most recent defeat at Watford that he’d never had such a run before in his managerial career. That is only true if you count a couple of League Cup matches at Stoke City in 2019/20, where he managed two Championship draws in the opening ten league fixtures.
He could hardly be blamed for wanting to forget that, although Stoke fans are unlikely to let him. Never, it’s safe to say, have Charlton had a boss who has made enemies of so many sets of opposition supporters. He’s done enough in SE7, however, for fans here to take a more nuanced view, however his tenure plays out. For now, he’s heavily in credit.
Already this term, he has delivered at least two memorable moments for Addicks supporters – 90-plus memorable minutes, actually, in the 2-1 win at West Ham United back in August, and more recently an instantly redemptive 96th-minute equaliser at Burnley, which ended him with him swinging from the dugout roof.
Jones can reasonably point to injuries having undermined the season’s fine start, but every manager knows they are an occupational hazard. The fact that the club continues to recruit players whose record in this respect is questionable reflects financial fragility not just judgement.
And if the current squad is still a jigsaw with missing pieces, there are players like Tyreece Campbell and Billy Koumetio who have shined more brightly than anticipated this season.
It’s rarely sensible to put too much weight on a single match that isn’t of itself decisive. Charlton go to Middlesbrough next week and won there, remarkably, last season.
Even so, it’s likely that the visit of Norwich City to The Valley this weekend provides the better opportunity to break the run. Like Charlton they have won three of their 11 league matches, the difference being they have lost all the rest.
All of which, a cynic is bound to suggest, points to a draw. But given Watford had conceded nine goals to Burnley and Cardiff City before they ran into Charlton, who knows? The prospect of injury victims Nathaniel Chalobah and Matty Godden rejoining Jones's squad is encouraging.
Things can change. Sometimes managers lose the plot completely, despite their past success. Older Addicks will recall that the club enjoyed much success under Andy Nelson, who also won promotion from the third tier in 1975. Eventually it all went wrong for him.
Powell (in 2011) and Bowyer (in 2019) each survived an 11-game winless streak. Nelson somehow weathered two such sequences of 11 and 15 games in consecutive seasons, but that was a different time.
Right now, however, a relatively stable set-up is battling to re-establish Charlton in what has become a fiercely competitive division. The result is often not very pretty and the team doesn’t score enough goals, but the priority is to find a way to win. Success is still measured by survival.
What is needed, alongside three points, is a sense of proportion in the stands as well as the boardroom if things don’t go well on Saturday. The Joneses needed are Nathan and defender Lloyd, not Clive Dunn’s beloved corporal from Dads' Army. Don’t panic. Yet!
Share