Cutty Sark slated as 'ugliest' building of year after restoration

New look Cutty Sark slated as the 'ugliest' building of the year New look Cutty Sark slated as the 'ugliest' building of the year

THE NEW look Cutty Sark has been slated as the ugliest building completed in the last year.

The restored Greenwich-based clipper ship – which was first built in 1869 – was awarded the Carbuncle Cup 2012 by website Building Design Online.

Following the derogatory prize, national heritage group The Victorian Society has branded the £50m refit “misguided”.

The ship reopened to visitors in April after substantial repair work following a fire in 2007.

The Victorian Society's new director Chris Costelloe said: “It's a pity that commercial motives were placed above heritage interests.

"The new design has obscured the Cutty Sark's distinctive shape at the quayside. Even the part of the ship we can still see includes an obtrusive lift tower looming over the deck.

He added: “Restoring heritage buildings for the 21st century doesn't have to mean misguided attempts to fit the corporate hospitality market.

"It is sad that such a high profile restoration has now led to the Cutty Sark being awarded the 2012 Carbuncle Cup.”

Comments(5)

GSAndy says...
8:53pm Mon 17 Sep 12

As a geriatric South Londoner I have visited the Cutty Sark many time over the last 50 years and was very sad to see the absolutely disastrous mess of a restoration.

It used to be a famous ship in a dry dock and a beautiful reminder of Britain's maritime history now it just looks ridiculous

joertmclark says...
8:16am Tue 18 Sep 12

I disagree. I think it looks brilliant. Not sure what everyone is crying about.

Guess who ;) AGAIN ! says...
10:48am Tue 18 Sep 12

Well I think its looks like a tea clipper, that's what it always was though.

eltham_girl says...
5:46pm Tue 18 Sep 12

It's a ship...how can it be voted ugliest BUILDING of the year??

Definition of building
noun
1a structure with a roof and walls, such as a house or factory.

Wefan1 says...
1:16pm Wed 19 Sep 12

It may be the latest Disneyfied attraction in Greenwich, but it does seem to have lost its soul. In it's previous, slightly dilapidated condition, at least we could understand the beauty of its lines, and the reality of its history. Chris Costelloe has sadly, got it right.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree