News RSS Feed


HAVE YOUR SAY: Entertainment Rant - cinema stinkers in 3D


Welcome to the first of News Shopper's Tuesday entertainment opinion columns. Read our rant and join the debate by adding your comments.

AS TIM Burton’s Alice In Wonderland boots James Cameron’s monster epic Avatar off the top of the UK film chart, it seems if you want to hear box office tills ring you’d better pimp your movie with the latest 3D effects.

As 3D fever grips the world, there’s no stopping studios investing in the eye-popping technology.

So far audiences have lapped it up – queuing fervently outside cinemas, clutching a pair of over-priced, ill-fitting glasses, hungry to gorge on a banquet of the latest visual delicacies.

While Alice and Avatar were great films in their own right, with or without the cool-to-be-nerdy specs, making characters and events seemingly jump out of the screen surely isn’t a guarantee of cinematic thrills and spills.

Most of the time 3D is an unnecessary distraction and a waste of time.

After the first half-hour of oohs and ahs, the vomit-inducing effects fade into the psychedelic background and what you are left with is, more often than not, a film which has about as much meat on its bones as a skeleton with an eating disorder.

MOVIE REVIEW: Alice In Wonderland ***

What it boils down to is a gimmick. An expensive one at that. But it is a gimmick which is enabling studios and film distributors to disguise their over-sized, stinking turkeys as well-fed, gourmet pheasants.

Just tag 3D onto the film’s title and no-one will notice the giant turd steaming at the centre of an expensive and glossy ad campaign.

So brace yourself this year for a rash of 3D movies and events which will leave your jaw rattling on the floor, not from wonderment, but from sheer disbelief anyone thought it worthwhile to spend time, effort and money to make even in two dimensions.

A new 3D Alvin and the Chipmunks film is just one well-polished stool sample to look forward to.

Rumours also suggest George Lucas may re-release all, yes all, his Star Wars films in 3D.

And elated by the success of Avatar, James Cameron has announced he may raise the Titanic (the film that is) from its soggy, forgotten depths and jazz it up using the new technology.

Oh and just in case you hadn't coughed up enough well-earned cash the first time, Cameron is planning another round of Avatar in the autumn. It's the stuff nightmares are made of.

This year also saw, for the first time, rugby broadcast in 3D, with whole pubs crammed full of bespectacled punters gawking at screens like hypnotised hamsters, mesmerised by a giant sesame seed.

It's only a matter of time before other TV programmes join the 3D revolution. How about soaking up some sun in 3D Neighbours? Or soak up the gore in Casualty?

Or if you're the only person in the world who still cares, why not pop on those glasses and experience what it's really like to live in the Big Brother house?

With reality only just about bearable in three dimensions, watching every piece of visual media in that format is a stomach churning thought.

This column in no way reflects the official position of News Shopper or its parent company.

What do you think? Is 3D the future of cinema or is it just a flash in the pan? What else would you like to see made in 3D? Add your comments below.

Check News Shopper's website every lunchtime for a new daily opinion column. Wednesday is a reader's rant, Thursday will cover a moral issue. Friday is sport, and Monday is back to the Shopper Rant on a topical news story. Be sure to have your say if you agree or disagree with what you read.


Comments(6)

pumpkinpie says...
1:09pm Tue 16 Mar 10

I went to see Christmas Carol in 3D, it was the first one we went to see in 3D. I was left feeling very sick by the effects of Scrooge flying all over london. Then came Avatar, we went to see it in 3D and I can't actually say it was worth it. It was a good film but didn't see the point of the 3D. We then saw Alice in Wonderland and again I don't think you necessarily need 3D to watch it.
I think it is a rip off but my partner enjoys the experience so I happily oblige. I am however looking forward to Toy story 3 in 3D! :o)

DrDBexley says...
4:32pm Tue 16 Mar 10

3D is revolutionising not only the way watch films at the cinema, thereby introducing some well needed funds in to this ailing industry (Avatar excepted) but is the next logicial step in home entertainment.

Cinema is the stepping stone or proving ground for emerging and therefore expensive technolgies. Just as F1 introduces a miriad of safety and other crucial features to day-to-day motoring, cinema is paramount to home enetertainment development. Dolby for instance, THX, digital imaging - all run in the first stages in the cinema. 3d is just the natural progression.

Already, 3D has a proven demand amongst consumers as a recent football match was screened using the technology. The World Cup is definately signed up for being broadcast in 3D and I'm sure the rugby world cup is also.

To say that it's unimportant is like saying that war is unimportant to the development of arms.

Yes, it might allow producers and film makers leaway to make a tripe film and gloss it over with visual 3D effects, but it's place is key to the development and progression of technologies, which will ultimately cost less. Think how HD TV's will fall in price when the new 3D TV's come on the market!

SeeSomeSense says...
5:19pm Tue 16 Mar 10

3D will never catch on, in my opinion. Most films that are released these days are bad enough in 2D without adding an extra dimension to their awfulness.

Take 1983's Jaws-3D for example. The 3D glasses really spoilt the film for me because I couldn't fit them over my existing distance glasses and I ended up removing the red and green filters and sticking them onto my prescription lenses with my own spittle. Even Michael Caine - the best actor the world has ever seen - couldn't stop me from leaving the auditorium before the film finished. Thank goodness The Swarm and Beyond The Poseidon Adventure were not ruined by being filmed in 3D!

porkpie says...
2:10pm Wed 17 Mar 10

SeeSomeSense wrote:
3D will never catch on, in my opinion. Most films that are released these days are bad enough in 2D without adding an extra dimension to their awfulness. Take 1983's Jaws-3D for example. The 3D glasses really spoilt the film for me because I couldn't fit them over my existing distance glasses and I ended up removing the red and green filters and sticking them onto my prescription lenses with my own spittle. Even Michael Caine - the best actor the world has ever seen - couldn't stop me from leaving the auditorium before the film finished. Thank goodness The Swarm and Beyond The Poseidon Adventure were not ruined by being filmed in 3D!
Michael Caine was in Jaws - The Revenge not Jaws 3D (Just know as Jaws 3. It starred Dennis Quaid (in his first lead role). It is the second sequel to Steven Spielberg's Jaws. At a SeaWorld type water park with underwater tunnels and lagoons. Both are very bad films. There is talk of making a new Jaws 3D film. 'Jaws' Rebooted? We're Gonna Need a Bigger Reason.

blueskies7 says...
3:58pm Wed 17 Mar 10

3d is just a waste of time for those of us whose eyes canot cope with refocusing at the accelerated speeds and proximity.

dave76 says...
4:56pm Sat 27 Mar 10

Older readers will remember the 3D fad back in the 1950s, "House Of Wax" the most memorable 3D effort then. If a movie is any good people will pay to see it. Hitchcocks "Dial M For Murder" was made in 3D but mostly shown in 2D, it was a good film and didn't need the 3D gimmik to make it popular.


Read News Shopper's daily opinion columns and have your say Read News Shopper's daily opinion columns and have your say

Most popular


When news happens – email newsdesk, call 01689 885703 or text keyword NEWS SHOPPER along with your news, pictures and videos to 80360.

Top stories for Bexley, Bromley, Lewisham and Greenwich and Dartford and Gravesend, and elsewhere in south east London and north Kent.

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses