Human rights barrister says legal aid cuts will lead to 'miscarriages of justice'

Human rights barrister tells News Shopper 'legal aid cuts will lead to miscarriages of justice'

Human rights barrister tells News Shopper 'legal aid cuts will lead to miscarriages of justice'

First published in News
Last updated
News Shopper: Photograph of the Author by , reporter

A leading human rights lawyer, who works across south east London, claims legal aid cuts will lead to “miscarriages of justice”.

David Malone - who regularly works in courts in Greenwich, Woolwich, Bexley and Bromley – is taking part in a demonstration in central London tomorrow.

The organised day of action, known as “#Graylingday” on Twitter, is set to cripple courts across the country as barristers and solicitors refuse to appear.

Mr Malone’s comments come as an Erith law centre is closing due to the £220m cuts however a Ministry of Justice spokesman told News Shopper legal aid must remain “sustainable”.

The proposals will see solicitors’ fees reduced by 17.5 per cent on average and barristers’ fees down by around 6 per cent.

Former Forest Hill resident Mr Malone said: “Justice Secretary Chris Grayling’s proposals will lead to miscarriages of justice.

“If we dismantle our legal system – which is the envy of the rest of the world – we will never be able to rebuild it again.

“I think all the courts across the country tomorrow will grind to a halt.

“But I don’t know a single person taking part in the day of action tomorrow who is happy about it.

“There is a real sense of worry and anxiety but it just shows the stage we’ve reached.”

Mr Malone said there is debate over whether they should demonstrate outside the Ministry of Justice in Westminster in their horse-hair wigs and gowns.

He said: “There is a bit of a Twitter storm about it.

“A lot of people see us in our wigs and gowns and think we’re a bunch of toffs but that is just our uniform – in the same way a doctor wears a stethoscope or an astronaut wears a suit.”

Mr Malone prosecutes and defends on a range of cases and said the changes will be particularly felt in south east London.

Pictured: The Cross Law Centre is closing due to the changes

News Shopper: Legal aid cuts force Erith Law Centre to close this month

He said: “It’s a double whammy which will reduce access to justice and access to the legal professions themselves.

“I didn’t come from a posh background at all – it was a single-parent, working-class family.

“These changes will decimate our system of justice and south east London will be the worse off because of it.

“The government says legal aid is spiralling out of control and is expensive but this is a bare-faced lie."

'Criminal barristers simply can't afford to pay their bills'

Fellow barrister Toby Hall, who also works across the News Shopper patch, said: "We've already been hit with savage cuts and many criminal barristers simply can't afford to pay their bills.

"People are already being forced to leave the profession and it's only going to get worse.

"The consequences of selling off justice will affect everyone in our society."

Ministry of Justice response

A Ministry of Justice spokesman said: "Legal aid is a vital part of our justice system but we must ensure it is sustainable for those who need it, for those who provide legal services as part of it and for the taxpayer, who ultimately pays for it.

"We have spoken at length with solicitors and barristers about these reforms and listened closely to their views.

“Our final plans announced last week reflect many of the changes they asked for.

"It does mean fee reductions, but it also includes a series of measures to ease their effect on lawyers.

"Agencies involved in the criminal justice system are taking steps to minimise any upset Friday’s court disruption could cause for victims and witnesses involved in trials.”

For more information, visit the Ministry of Justice website.

What do you think of #Graylingday? Leave your comments below.

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

3:14pm Thu 6 Mar 14

Carparkattendant says...

Not if he continues to do his job properly. What he means is that there will be less money in it for parasites like him !
Not if he continues to do his job properly. What he means is that there will be less money in it for parasites like him ! Carparkattendant
  • Score: 4

4:58pm Thu 6 Mar 14

SidcupResident says...

Or it'll mean less frivolous "yuman wights" cases being brought to the courts, and only a one week holiday in the Bahamas this year for the barristers as opposed to a fortnight, and one less sports car....
Or it'll mean less frivolous "yuman wights" cases being brought to the courts, and only a one week holiday in the Bahamas this year for the barristers as opposed to a fortnight, and one less sports car.... SidcupResident
  • Score: 4

7:57pm Thu 6 Mar 14

oBLiVioN 70 says...

I agree these cuts will lead to miscarriages of justice but the line that says they cannot afford to pay their bills?

Solicitors and barristers have studied hard and are paid very well, they do deserve to reap the rewards for that work and only the inept or compassionate will take legal aid cases in some parts of the UK, but we have been getting more like the USA for years anyway.

Greed on their part is partly to blame for this.
I agree these cuts will lead to miscarriages of justice but the line that says they cannot afford to pay their bills? Solicitors and barristers have studied hard and are paid very well, they do deserve to reap the rewards for that work and only the inept or compassionate will take legal aid cases in some parts of the UK, but we have been getting more like the USA for years anyway. Greed on their part is partly to blame for this. oBLiVioN 70
  • Score: 7

6:11pm Fri 7 Mar 14

white rabbit9 says...

NWO, destroy the justice system.
NWO, destroy the justice system. white rabbit9
  • Score: 4

4:31pm Sun 9 Mar 14

sarfflondonbird says...

It's only because their fees are being cut that they give a ****, human rights cases are a lucrative business for them, after all human right infringements can be found somewhere in any case if they look hard enough. It's time to stop being so generous with the tax payers hard earned wage and bring these parsites in to the real world.
It's only because their fees are being cut that they give a ****, human rights cases are a lucrative business for them, after all human right infringements can be found somewhere in any case if they look hard enough. It's time to stop being so generous with the tax payers hard earned wage and bring these parsites in to the real world. sarfflondonbird
  • Score: 2

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree