Silent Witness complaints logged

Emilia Fox plays Nikki Alexander in Silent Witness Emilia Fox plays Nikki Alexander in Silent Witness

The BBC has apologised after screening brutal scenes in its popular drama series Silent Witness which prompted nearly 500 complaints.

More than six million people saw the BBC1 forensic pathology programme - starring actress Emilia Fox - on Sunday, which climaxed with a scene depicting the aftermath of a savage beating.

The BBC said it received 483 complaints from viewers who felt the story, which had a further instalment the following night, was "too violent".

In the footage, the twitching, moaning body of one character was seen in a pool of blood being kicked in a toilet cubicle. His attacker was then seen preparing to resume the beating with a baseball bat although the gory detail was not shown.

The BBC said: "We acknowledge that certain scenes may have been challenging but we filmed and presented them in such a way as to make sure that although as a viewer the implication was there, it was never actually shown."

Both programmes were flagged up with warnings about the violent content and the corporation said the series is known for "challenging stories" and "adult themes".

It added: "We don't feel the content of these episodes would have gone beyond viewers' expectations."

In a statement on its complaints website, the BBC continued: "As programme makers we take our responsibility to the audience extremely seriously and try to make sure we strike the right balance between compelling drama without being unnecessarily graphic."

It added: "We're sorry if you felt we got it wrong on this occasion."

Comments(6)

keskendra says...
4:46pm Thu 26 Apr 12

oh ffs it's 9pm, get over it. I am sick and tired of the nappy state. I only watch channel 4. Much more mature and able to cater to lots of different views. sick of paying TV licence for total crap and total watered down patronising views. Give me a stiff drink any day!

spamfiend says...
9:21pm Thu 26 Apr 12

Plenty of warnings before and during the ad breaks and people still complain, and add to this the fact that people know the nature of this programme makes me doubt the sensibility of some people. I watch NCIS on freesat and whilst not as violent sometimes as Silent Witness, there are plenty of scenes showing the bodies on the autopsy table for example yet it still gets shown with a warning at the start.
As keskendra makes a point of saying we are becoming a nappy state, I am afraid I wholeheartedly agree!!

spamfiend says...
9:22pm Thu 26 Apr 12

Plenty of warnings before and during the ad breaks and people still complain, and add to this the fact that people know the nature of this programme makes me doubt the sensibility of some people. I watch NCIS on freesat and whilst not as violent sometimes as Silent Witness, there are plenty of scenes showing the bodies on the autopsy table for example yet it still gets shown with a warning at the start.
As keskendra makes a point of saying we are becoming a nappy state, I am afraid I wholeheartedly agree!!

spamfiend says...
9:22pm Thu 26 Apr 12

Plenty of warnings before and during the ad breaks and people still complain, and add to this the fact that people know the nature of this programme makes me doubt the sensibility of some people. I watch NCIS on freesat and whilst not as violent sometimes as Silent Witness, there are plenty of scenes showing the bodies on the autopsy table for example yet it still gets shown with a warning at the start.
As keskendra makes a point of saying we are becoming a nappy state, I am afraid I wholeheartedly agree!!

spamfiend says...
9:22pm Thu 26 Apr 12

Plenty of warnings before and during the ad breaks and people still complain, and add to this the fact that people know the nature of this programme makes me doubt the sensibility of some people. I watch NCIS on freesat and whilst not as violent sometimes as Silent Witness, there are plenty of scenes showing the bodies on the autopsy table for example yet it still gets shown with a warning at the start.
As keskendra makes a point of saying we are becoming a nappy state, I am afraid I wholeheartedly agree!!

ponderman says...
9:38am Fri 27 Apr 12

These 'people' should grow up, if all they want to do is complain, then complain about something that matters like having to work all week and still ending up skint.
Why are some people trying to create an over-censored, over-regulated society, what about using one's own discretion on what to watch, the show in question is on after the watershed so what the hell is the problem?
This site needs sorting out, keep getting error message everytime I try and comment, this is the cause of so many repeated comments.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree